|
Online News Magazine written by Robert Niepert mayorbob@embarqmail.com This News Magazine, its articles, photos and all the
General Information Sick Call........David Rose (Kockritz Rifles of 7th Fla. Co. B Infantry C.S.A. and S.C.V. Florida Division, 14th Brig.) made it through his cancer surgery last week but is not doing well. His wife Sharon and family are overwhelmed with the sad situation. Dave traveled all over the country attending reenactments in many states. Additionally he played as an extra actor in films like Gettysburg and Glory. Dave has made many friends and made a positive impression for our Southern Heritage. Dave has been a good influence on all that he have come in contact with him. He represented his Southern heritage by bravely serving on the front lines in Vietnam and came back to Palm Beach County. In West Palm Beach, he has been the cornerstone of not only his immediate family and friends and a positive influence at the South Florida Fairgrounds in the YesterYear Village. The Rose family had requested no visitors or phone calls. There is a benefit car show for Dave and his family being planned by "Stripper" at the YesterYear Village for March. 28th. Donations for David will also be collected at Olustee in the C.S.R.S. (Confederate States Recruiting Service) Living History tent. Editors note...This information came to me by way of ... SCV/Fla. Div.14th Brig. Cdr. L.J. Powell Pvt Powell "Kockritz Rifles" 7th Fla. Co. B. Inf. C.S.A. For more information see the "Letters To The Magazine" section in this issue. Reenactor Passes Away.........George Sheets, the commander of the Fl. 5th since the 1980's, passed away on Saturday, Jan 24. He had been ill for many years and had to retire from reenacting in 2000. All reenactors who have been in the hobby for any length of time should remember our gallant, gray-haired George who led us in so many Battles of Ft. Myers. Please keep his family in your thoughts and prayers. Olustee School Day........The event hosts at the Olustee reenactment need help with their school day program (Friday the 13th) If you are interested in volunteering, please contact them at olusteecso@yahoo.com Found at Brooksville.........Sgt. Brian Wysong (7th Connecticut Volunteer Infantry) found a knife at the last Brooksville event. He would like to return it to its owner. If it is your knife, contact Brian at robkatdav@aol.com Reenactor Found...........Clint Oak who moved to Arkansas a while back has a new email address. If you would like to email him, he can be reached at ceoak@alltell.net If you remember, Clint formed the Southern Artillery Brigade here in Florida. Drop him an email if you like. Recruits Needed...........This past weekend at Mt. Dora, we had to say goodbye to Company A. of the 3rd Rhode Island Light Artillery. Manning problems, the bane of all artillery units finally did us in. Left with the choice of leaving the hobby and people we love, or trying something just a bit different, we went with different. So as the 3rd Rhode Island Light faded in the distance, we said hello to Company A., 3rd Rhode Island Heavy Artillery. It seems like a small change, but one that we hope will prove effective. Heavy Artillery is a bit different, as units are issued with rifles and accoutrements just like the infantry. The goal of our new unit is to be able to place at least a company strength unit on the field, and draw from this company to place our field piece in line. It seems like quite a task but when all is said and done, no one will be able to accuse us of not trying. We are hoping that the 3rd will appeal to those veteran reenactors that want to try to blow some "Big Powder" but aren't ready to give up the musket yet. New members can get a grounding in two of the three branches of reenacting. It will give everyone a chance to participate in the manner they are most comfortable with on any given day. This change will also allow us the versatility to occasionally run "scenarios". The uniform will be the same for both cannon crew and riflemen. Federal four button sack coat, black slouch hat with red hat cord, Red Chevrons and other rank insignia. Brass and additional red will be subdued. Anyone with an interest in the 3rd Rhode Island Heavy Artillery in invited to contact 1st Sgt. Rick Nigh at a3rdrila@hotmail.com Olustee Living History.......Pat McAlhany (Columbia County Historical Museum & Historical Sewing Society) wanted to make the following announcement. She wrote........ I would like to share some of the excitement about the Living History Event that will be hosted by the Columbia County Historical Museum in Lake City in conjunction with the Battle of Olustee Commemoration. As many of you have read in our Historical Sewing Society posts, the focus of this event will be to depict what civilians in Lake City would have been doing in preparation for the wounded being transported there from the battlefield. Records reflect that the Cathey House on North Marion Street was used as a hospital after the Battle of Olustee and that the wounded from both armies were cared for by citizens of Lake City. So..........now that the stage is set, we would like to ask for a favor AND also invite any "Soldiers" who happen to passing through Lake City en route to the battlefield to visit the Museum! We could sure use a stream of candidates for care by our skilled, civilian staff! We will be actively hustling around the Museum on Friday the 13th and Saturday the 14th from 9:00 AM - 5:00PM. It would be wonderful to have some walking wounded stagger in for some attention and nourishment!!! Seriously - if you are going to be in town for the parade and can come participate in this part of the Olustee Event - it would really add to the level of authenticity we are so seriously trying to present. Now that the invitation has been extended, - the favor we seek: The clotheslines surrounding the porches of the "hospital" would have been filled to capacity with laundered bedding, bandages and UNIFORMS. We are making bandages and have created bedding - but we lack UNIFORMS!!! If anyone has uniforms - parts of uniforms, tattered or torn uniforms - WE DESPERATELY NEED THEM for display purposes. We will be careful with them and guarantee that they will not be lost or taken if entrusted to our care. In addition, in exchange for use of these precious possessions - we will offer our skills as "Historical Sewing Society" members and we can mend and make whatever minor repairs might be required before returning you uniforms! I will gladly pick up and deliver the uniforms and sign whatever you would wish to have to insure the safety of your property! The event at the Museum will compliment the activities at the
battlefield
by displaying another aspect of life at the time of the Battle of
Olustee.
Please help us with our first effort to present an authentic and
memorable
living history experience.
Most Sincerely,
Fort Clinch Weekend Moved.......Capt. Fred Jakobson emailed me the following information........ This e-mail is to inform you that I have had to change the date of the Fort Clinch event due to a conflict in their schedule. The new date for the Fort Clinch Garrison will be February 27th, 28th and 29th. The last weekend in February will be the new date for Fort Clinch in the future. This will be to our advantage as it will be cooler weather and will give us an additional event in February other than Olustee. We will have an off weekend between Olustee and Fort Clinch and an off weekend between Fort Clinch and Crystal River. I hope that will be a better schedule for you. Please contact me as soon as possible if you plan to attend. Sincerely, Capt. Fred Jakobson csarooster@adelphia.net March 19, 20, 21, 2004. The St. Andrews event will NOT OCCUR this year. The event had been planned last year and was to have taken place in March, 2004. The motel next to the St. Andrews downtown park has recently been razed and there is significant construction of condominiums in progress on the old motel site. The event hosts are not presently able to sponsor the event as originally planned. Hopefully they can come up with a plan of action for a future event. The event may be held sometime in 2005. I will keep you informed if I hear any new news about this event. May 1, 2, 2004. Canceled Spring Garden Plantation Raid at Camp Winona. Has been canceled. There will not be a Spring Garden event this year. If you have any questions, email Keith Kohl at cog4flainf@aol.com Two western North Carolina residents' views on the recent film. by Mike Hardy Jr. As residents of the landscape upon which the story of Cold Mountain is largely laid, we have perhaps a different insight into the film's accuracy and value. First of all, the war here in Appalachia was not like the war in other places. It was nasty, and it was personal. Strange soldiers might burn a person's barn or shoot his cow, but it was just as likely that the brutality was performed by neighbors, even relatives. In this region, there was not just one enemy. For those who, like the vast majority of western North Carolinians, were Confederate in their sympathies, death or destruction could come at the hands of wandering Union soldiers, either under orders or escaping from a prison; from Home Guard or other officials who did not care where one's loyalties lay; or from any number of people who just used the war as an excuse to, as we say, "get up to meanness." In this regard, the film is actually tame in its portrayal, as Sarah is not actually raped, and Sally Swanger recovers, albeit only partially, from her brutal treatment at the hands of Teague and his men. These events were actually based on real crimes against civilians, all perpetrated just a few miles from the scenic Blue Ridge Parkway and ski slopes where tourists now enjoy themselves. Long before this film was made, we used examples of some of these atrocities in our programs about civilians. The woman whose thumbs were crushed under the log fence was very real, and women in the mountains, like Ruby and Ada, often did have to fend for themselves. In the portrayal of women, the film is actually quite accurate, since it spans the gamut from the depraved women who lure in deserters to the gentle and earthy goat woman, to the remarkable Ruby (yes, an Oscar for Ms. Z, whose accent is right up the hollar). The Rubys and the Sallys of this area were numerous. We have read their letters and touched the walls of their homes. Their stories are often far more tragic and painful than anything Hollywood could produce and still turn a profit. One of our favorite touches was the use of music. The shape-note songs were fantastic and used beautifully. This is a style of music we have enjoyed for years, so it's nice to see it getting some national attention. Yes, the film has flaws. Ada's hair drove us crazy (take some hair hints from the charming lady visiting Inman in the hospital and slick that stuff down!). Ms. Kidman is far more beautiful and fashionable than the Ada of the novel, but her wardrobe is quite flawed, both in the book and in the movie (She should have taken fashion hints from the incomparable Jewel in Ride with the Devil!). The Home Guard was not formed until mid-1863, not at the start of the war as the film depicts. Inman's excellent North Carolina uniform would not have been issued to him before he marched off to war. However, despite its flaws, the film is important in that it draws attention, at last, to Appalachia's peculiar brand of suffering and civil war. For those wishing to learn more about the war in Western North Carolina, check out Bushwhackers, by Trotter and the Heart of Confederate Appalachia by Inscoe and McKinney. This area of scholarship is our specialty, so if you want to chat with us further, we'd love to hear from you! Michael and Elizabeth Hardy mchardy@hotmail.com by Kathy Heitman, Photos by Kathy "The Picture Lady" Sgt. Maj. David "Davie" Rose, one of the original members of the 7th Florida Co. B Volunteer Infantry Regiment C.S.A., known as the "Straw Hats" has been dealt a very serious blow. He was recently diagnosed with pancreatic cancer. Before he went to surgery on January 29th, his doctor gave him two options: (1) the operation would be successful in removing the pancreas thereby eliminating the insidious cancer or (2) the surgeon would try to bypass the tumor, do what he could, sew David up and send him home. Sadly, the latter is the case, as the tumor is too far-gone. David has been given 1-5 months to live. He was still in hospital February 5th. I don't know when he'll be going home. He's lost an incredible amount of weight, doesn't look or act like himself, doesn't speak much...understandably. David is the kind of man that is nothing short of a big teddy bear underneath his seemingly tough exterior. David is the sort of individual that you have to love like a brother, get frustrated with when he is being stubborn or want to slap when he is "pushing your buttons", only to melt when you see the look in his eye and silly grin on his face when you realize he is kidding. My husband Jack and I have known Davie and his family since the mid-90's. We feel we've known him forever because David made us feel at ease immediately. We love him dearly. We met his wife Sharon and daughter Amber a short time after we met him. About 6 years ago, we had the thrill of meeting his grandson, Casey, when he was born. It is because of David Rose that my husband Jack is a member of the 7th Florida Co. B. At Davie's urging, Jack signed on as a Pvt. at the Markham Park reenactment in South Florida in January 1998. We watched the battle and couldn't wait until our first reenactment - Olustee 1998. It's because of David Rose that we have the privilege of having met so many of you we call friends. As I've stated above, Davie is one of the original members of the 7th Florida Co. B. He was in the unit when Ewald Kockritz commanded it. He was in the unit when Mike Crane took the helm. He was in the unit when Mike Crane turned the command over to Bob Todd. Davie will always be Sgt. Maj. David Rose, 7th Florida Co. B. Sgt. Maj. Rose has been in several movies about the American Civil War, his most famous role, at least according to Davie himself, was in the movie Gettysburg. The last reenactment Davie attended was Hunsader Farms 2003. He dressed out the entire weekend, but wasn't able to take the field. He was too sick. I remember sitting under my motorhome canopy with Davie, laughing and reminiscing about the fun he, Jack and I have had since we met. He got quiet, looked down at his hands and said to me in a small voice, "Kathy I know I've told you this before, but would you make sure that when I die, they play and sing "The Vacant Chair" at my funeral?" My reply was, "Of course I will." Davie had tears in his eyes. So did I. I've included a photo I took at Hunsader Farms back in 2002. I chose this particular photograph because there is a funny story behind it, but I won't go into that. For years, Davie was a member of Yesteryear Village at the South Florida Fairgrounds. He was the committee head of the Old Veterans Home Civil War Museum building just inside the Archway Gate entrance on the north side of the Village. Many items inside the Museum were articles from Davie's private collection. Up until the night before he went into hospital two weeks prior to his surgery, he was helping the South Florida Fairgrounds ready the passenger shuttle for the South Florida Fair scheduled to begin shortly after. He never stopped. He took great pride in regaling everyone with stories of the ghost he called "Ugly Man" that roamed at will in the Old Veterans Home Civil War Museum. Each time we saw Davie, it seemed that Ugly Man was up to his usual bag of tricks. I think Davie developed a sort of affection for the old geezer. Ugly Man wasn't the only story Davie had to tell. He could keep you enthralled or in stitches for hours with stories of this foray or that experience he'd had. He especially liked to tell the story of "Wild Man" up in Georgia close to where the infamous Civil War train "The General" was housed. When Jack and I would return, one of the first things Davie would as was, "Did ya see Wild Man?" David's middle name is "Stories". David is also a proud Southerner. He is one of the original members of the James Patton Anderson Camp #1599 Sons of Confederate Veterans in Palm Beach County, FL. He participated in many activities hosted by the Camp, even picked up trash on the side of the road when the Camp was called upon. He helped Compatriot Larry Powell with his S.C.V. display at the Olustee, FL and Ft. Pierce, FL reenactments and at various Yesteryear Village events. Davie participated in annual Confederate Memorial Day ceremonies at Woodlawn Cemetery in West Palm Beach, FL. He helped clean and decorate southern soldiers' graves in cemeteries around Palm Beach County, FL. David is and always will be a proud Southerner. A few days ago, the Yesteryear Village Council Chairman contacted me about a fund raiser that will be hosted for the Rose family in Yesteryear Village at the South Florida Fairgrounds. It's hoped that flyers and tickets will be printed soon. As of this writing, the original date has been pushed back one week to March 28th from 10 A.M. till 4 P.M. There will be hot dogs, hamburgers, etc. Village Volunteers will have their respective buildings open to the public. There will be pony rides for the children. My husband Jack will be giving train rides with the miniature train he built. If you would like to get a card or a note to Davie or his family, you can give it to me this weekend at Olustee. My motorhome will be parked directly behind the sutlers on the south side as you enter modern camping. Just look for the flamingos...can't miss 'em (smile). For those of you who believe in the power of prayer - for those of you who believe miracles still happen, please pray. Please pray hard. Please put the Rose family on prayer chains and in prayer groups at your church or synagogue. For those of you who are not subscribers to such, please do whatever you think best to help the Rose family through this time of trial. Even if you did not know Davie, let him and his family know that, as fellow reenactors and living historians, you are behind them. They need all the encouragement we can give them. We need to be faithful and diligent in our daily life to get Davie the miracle he and his family desperately need. Thank you. See you at Olustee! Kathy Heitman
Several days prior to this incident, I had developed a lingering cold that was akin to a slow burning forest fire in its intensity and complimented by the wet and cold/humid atmosphere, that was a time bomb awaiting to explode...which it indeed did. At approximately 8 PM I retired for the evening and was exhausted due to the underlying illness....this "Cold" simmered and chest congestion followed and grew so severe that I could not draw a single breath and coughed so hard I threw up and fought for each breath...I was on the edge of passing out for lack of air. Each breath seemed like my last, and may have well been. My wife called for help and Doc Riker arrived...he triaged the situation and calmed an otherwise less than calm patient and patient's wife. He did determine that the extent of my distress was severe and reasoned that a 911 response from Rescue was required. He remained with me until Rescue arrived and assisted them. I was treated by Rescue, administered oxygen and given drugs to assist my breathing.....transported to Waterman Hospital and treated at the ER.....Diagnosis.......Severe airway obstruction and lack of air exchange..meaning I was drowning in my own fluids. After several hours, I was treated, determined to out of immediate danger and released with an armful of drugs and some sore lungs and airway( not to mention a large bill for Ambulance and ER treatment and ER Doctor treatment..thank God for insurance). The ER Doctor did tell me that a short while longer and I may well have developed pneumonia and could have passed out causing my airway to close off and may have well died in my sleep if not for the quick determination of the first responder....Doc Riker being that responder. Doc...THANK YOU more than I can ever relate and when I say I owe you one..I mean it from the bottom of my sometimes seemingly hard heart. Throughout the entire situation, one thing seems to stand out in my fogged and cloudy mind that late evening..that Doc was barefoot in the cold and nasty weather and responded so fast he never had a chance to care for himself before caring for me. Allow me to bring to your attention the caliber of person that
stands
by to treat us at these re-enactments and his dedication to that
effort.
Doc..THANK YOU again. I am in your debt, you may well have saved my life( for whatever it may be worth)
Greetings to one and all! At the recent re-enactment of
Townsend's
Plantation in Mount Dora, I met with the re-enactor committee that has
organized the Spring Garden Plantation Raid re-enactment at Camp Winona
YMCA camp near Deland. While the 4th Florida Infantry has been
the
host unit for the event, the re-enactor committee was made up of
re-enactors
from several units. During the meeting, the re-enactor committee
elected to discontinue the Spring Garden re-enactment. We have
arrived
at this decision through no distrust of the Camp Winona staff, any of
the
re-enactors who have assisted with the organizing, or those who have
supported
the re-enactment. Simply, the demands of the event have increased
and the ranks of the re-enactor committee have thinned.
Therefore,
faced with meeting increased financial and logistical needs of the
event
with less resources and staff, we have decided that if we could not do
the event right, we would discontinue it. We wish to extend our
warmest
thanks to the Camp Winona staff who have been very cooperative in
working
with us the past few years and this year for allowing us to have the
event
on their site, to all those who have helped organize the event, and to
all who have attended the re-enactment.
Major Keith Kohl, commanding
Key West Heritage Days by Lt. R. K. Garvin 25th OVI The 18th Annual Key West Heritage Days was held Jan. 23-25 in Key West Florida at Fort Taylor. For those who do not know, Taylor was one of the third system coastal forts began in the 1840's and completed before the War. When anti-Northern sentiment began rising in Key West, it was occupied by a force of only 44 Union soldiers. It was held throughout the War and played a significant role in defending the coast and shutting down blockade runners. Some of the Regiments stationed there included the 90th New York, the 47th Penn. and the 2nd USCT. I got down there early Friday morning and set up in the fort. Col. Rick Reichard was commanding the Federal forces and Col. Rick Brass commanded the Confederates. the event was lightly attended, probably due to Brooksville being held the weekend before. This also marks one of the few events in the South where Yanks outnumber Rebs, at least this year. Friday night was spent carousing in town and generally relaxing from the trip. Although it was quite a trip for me, for others it was shorter or longer. Col. Reichard came all the way from Maryland. Saturday morning came early and it promised to be a nice warm day, better than the cold I had left in Jacksonville. Key West in January is usually around 70-75 degrees during the day with lows at night around 60-65. Perfect reenacting weather! Units in attendance were the 47th Penn., the 13th Ind, the 25th OVI and a Berdans, as well as Col. Brass' contingent of Rebs. Colors took place, and , after a hearty breakfast, we loaded up onto the Conch Train, the local tourist transportation, to head into town for the parade. The parade started at Mallory Square and we proceeded to march across the island. We had the whole town's attention as we smartly proceeded down the road behind the police escort, with Col.. Riechard leading, followed by the main body of Yanks, Rebs and civilians. the march was a short one and not too hard. We reached Southard St., near the fort , where we broke and headed back to the fort and our tents. Lunch came around and again we were inundated with food from the Fort's volunteers. After lunch, Col. Riechard had told me we were short of Rebs, so myself and some of the Yanks galvanized and loaded up in Park service vehicles to head down to Key West Harbor to board the Wolf, a 18th Century sailing vessel whose Captain, Finbar, uses to fight a mock battle between the Fort and a blockade runner. I thought this was a pretty good deal........reenact and get a free cruise at the same time! We boarded the Wolf, and after we exited the harbor, Finbar's youthful crew raised the sail, he shut the engine down and we were under way. We rounded the point and began battle with the fort's batteries and infantry. After an hour, it became apparent that it would wind up a draw and the Wolf pulled away and headed out to sea for a short cruise. The excursion was a pleasant one and the women came up from below to partake in the healthful winds and sun warming us all. Soon, Finbar headed back to port and our cruise was over. Once back in the fort, we settled in for the day with expectations for the ball and another excellent meal. It seems that the fort had invited the 97th Penn. String Band and we were entertained by Rick Mook and his minstrels for the evening. After the ball, which was well attended, some turned in for the night, while some slipped into town for libations and some modern entertainment. Sunday beamed bright and early and Colors were held. A special ceremony was held for the former Confederate Commanding Officer who had passed away recently promoting him to Brigadier General posthumously. Lunch again was served and was great. The fort really feeds you well! The Wolf was not to go out today, so we waited for any sign of blockade runners to appear. Sure enough, around 2 PM a ship was spotted, the Western Union, and a sprightly exchange followed. We were able to drive her off, but, while relaxing after the battle, the America slipped past our guns probably on one of her trips to Nassau. The sentry on duty was summarily punished for not giving the alarm in time. All in all, the event was a good one and could use some work. Confederates are needed and some polishing up will be done for next year. I took vacation and was able to stay in the park if I wished for the time I was down there. It does save money as most of the lodging in town is expensive and the Fort and the Rangers are very accommodating. Next year, the event is scheduled for the last weekend in January, two weeks after Brooksville and two weeks before Olustee and the weekend before the Super Bowl, Jan. 29-30. Come down, thaw out, and have some fun! Lt. R. K. Garvin 25th OVI More On The Key West Event...........Maj. Brass (10th Tenn. Co. A.) wrote.......The weather was perfect, hog roast Saturday night with the 97th Regimental String band, The "Sea Battle" was good also, we took out the "Sea Wolf" which is a 120 Ft. Pirate ship, complete with cannons that fired once every 10 seconds! I was in command of 15 rifles and the Captain was shooting with one hand and steering with the other. Positioned on the beach was a 3 inch Ordnance rifle and a mortar. The one bad thing was that we lacked Confederates, we only had enough for a small color guard. The Federals broke their record with 25. Next year the park rangers will let us set up and camp in the Fort. This is a first, this has never happened before. You need to think on this event for next year, it will be the last weekend of Jan. between Brooksville and the Super Bowl, see you at Olustee. Major Rick Brass Mt. Dora
I can't remember when was the last time it rained at the Mt.
Dora event
and I won't forget how much it rained this year. Yes, rain and
rain
it did. The "liquid sunshine" started falling (not too heavy, on
then off) late Friday and didn't stop until just before the battle
Sunday.
It may have been wet but the rain didn't dampen the spirits of the 300
+ or - reenactors who came to do battle. All photos in this
article
were taken by Kathy Heitman (aka. the picture lady).
Crimes And Punishments In The Civil War PART ONE Crimes And Offences by Robert A. Niepert Throughout time all armies have found it necessary to maintain some form of discipline and the Civil War was no exception to the rule. When the armies of the north and south formed up and officers and enlisted men were learning their place and respective duties, there were three times the number of punishments administered for poor behavior as in the latter two years of the war. This is in part due to several circumstances. In the last years, the Confederate army was totally consumed with its survival and the Union army was pushing hard for a victory. The rigors of the marches into position and then into battle, the months spent campaigning the hardships jointly endured by all from privates to generals and the unity towards a common goal brought the men together. There were still discipline problems but only the gravest of crimes warranted attention. As the war drug on, trivial offences were committed but they were often ignored. Types
Of
Courts Martial.....For the most serious infractions, officers were
usually subjected to a General courts martial and enlisted men were
dealt
with in Regimental or Garrison courts martial. The General courts
martial (photo at left) was convened by a general staff officer or a
colonel.
The Regimental courts martial was a panel of three officers (up to a
maximum
of thirteen) headed by the regimental or corps commander's
appointee.
The panel was made up of commissioned officers only excluding
chaplains,
surgeons, paymasters. The Garrison courts martial included a
panel
headed by the garrison commander's appointee for charges against the
soldiers
within forts and camps. The Drumhead was not really a formal
courts
martial and could be called by any commander for any reason while in
the
field; furthermore, legal formalities were usually disregarded.
The
Drumhead type of courts martial led to a wide range of inequities as
the
officers used their own judgment and meted out what they perceived to
be
fair punishments.
In all types of courts martials, a judge advocate was appointed to represent the government (same for Union or Confederate) whose job it was to prosecute. The problem with the judge advocate was that he was also to represent and defend the accused and additionally had the right to prevent "any record from being made...which (might) influence...the witnesses whose testimony is yet to be delivered." Men could be beat or bribed into making confessions and leading questions could be used to confuse the accused. The cards were clearly stacked in favor of the army. The problem with courts martials was that the military justice system requires witnesses for prosecution and defense. Witnesses often were killed or missing in action and the officers required to sit on the board were not always available. In addition to that problem, there were no specific guidelines for most minor to semi-serious offences as they were not covered by the military code. Before any appropriate punishments could be administered, a courts martial board as specified in article 66 of the Customs of Service had to vote with a two to one majority in agreement that a punishable crime had been committed. There were no pardons except from the commanding general or from Presidents Davis or Lincoln. The accused could challenge a decision made by the court but the court did not have to consider the challenge to their decision if they didn't want to. As you can see, the courts martial system of military justice is clearly contrary to the Constitution. Punishment for crimes or behaviorisms was not limited to the enlisted men and non-commissioned officers only; however, enlisted men suffered far greater punishments than did the officers. For example, an enlisted man if found drunk was often sentenced to wear a ball and chain for a month while an officer committing the same offence more often than not was not punished at all. Officers were subject to and frequently were tried for their offenses. More often than not, the sentence administered to the officer was limited to the less severe punishments of fines, confinement to quarters or assignment to an undesirable command. In cases of high disgrace, the offending officer was expected to resign. The infantry, cavalry and artillery handled their discipline problems in much the same way but the Navies of both the North and South dealt with their discipline problems differently. Aboard ship there was no place large enough to set up a punishment area and the lack of personnel prohibited most corporal punishments. The Captain of the ship dispensed justice as he saw fit. The punishments were usually in the form of fines, extra duty, time in the brig, confinement in single or double irons, confinement on bread and water, solitary confinement, or reduction in rank. There were literally hundreds of circumstances and behaviors during the Civil War that resulted in punishable offences committed by both officers and enlisted men. Some men were guilty of serious crimes, some intentionally misbehaved to avoid the problems of camp life, while others were just in the wrong place at the wrong time. General McClellan often complained about the leniency demonstrated by sentences handed down from the courts martial boards. He felt that softer punishments encouraged the perpetration of crimes. McClellan himself confirmed five death penalty sentences. Approximately 500 soldiers (north and south combined) were executed for capital crimes. The Union army's records show that they executed 267 men. This included 147 deserters, 67 murderers, 19 mutineers, 23 rapists and 11 others for various crimes. Overall, the unit commanders held the record for the most severe punishments (not including the death penalty). They were able to arbitrarily sentence men while in the field in a drumhead courts martial. Defying Orders........You may think at first that defying orders was a problem with the common soldier but in fact this problem manifested itself most often within the ranks of the officers. Union Brigadier General Henry Washington was arrested on June 19, 1862 for disobeying Major General David Hunter's direct written order not to advance upon the Confederate Fort Johnson and Secessionville. Washington was weary of being harassed by the Confederate artillery and attacked the fort even after his fellow officers advised against it and he had been ordered not to do it. The assault was attempted on June 16, 1862 and within twenty-five minutes more than 500 Federal soldiers lay dead or wounded. The General should have been convicted of a serious crime in the death of so many men but instead, after the intervention of the President, he was relieved of his command and his brigadier commission revoked. Brigadier General Henry Washington was reassigned to engineering duties with the Army of the Potomac and remained there throughout the war. In some cases, defying orders escalated into outright insubordination and sometimes violence. The ninth article of war stated that any violence toward an officer could be punished by death. Sleeping While On Duty........Guard duty for many reasons was the most dreaded part of a soldier's routine duties. Hundreds of men fell asleep while trying to perform this job. It was mentioned in many letters home like the one below. "I saw my first example of "Army discipline" today - and don't like it one bit. Tommy McKearnan fell asleep on guard duty last night. After all, it had been a long day, what with the skirmish then the ride down to here. Tommy was beat before his squad drew the guard. He was caught by the sergeant of the guard early this morning, and placed under arrest. They didn't even bother much with a trial - he was guilty anyway. As punishment, they've stripped him down to his underwear, and are making him wear a barrel around camp with a sign on it "I Fell Asleep" He'll probably be back on duty tomorrow.
Art: 46. Any sentinel who shall be found sleeping upon his post, or shall leave it before he shall be regularly relieved, shall suffer death, or such other punishment as shall be inflicted by the sentence of a court martial.
Art. 45. Any commissioned officer who shall be found drunk on his guard, party, or other duty, shall be cashiered. Any non-commissioned officer or soldier so offending shall suffer such corporeal punishment as shall be inflicted by the sentence of a court-martial.
Art. 29. No sutler shall be permitted to sell any kind of liquors .. (etc. and goes on to state) .. on the penalty of being dismissed from all future sutling.
"The one that was shot today was not killed dead the first fire." he noted. "Consequently he was shot twice. You can not imagine how cruel it looks to see a man shot. Twelve men shot at him at about ten steps; Only one ball hit him in the side. He fell over on his face, was examined by the surgeon. who pronounced him not dead. Two men were then ordered out with loaded muskets who shot him dead. It looks very barbarous to see men shot in that way but it is necessary to maintain the discipline of an army."
Art. 20. All officers and soldiers who have received pay, or have been duly enlisted in the service of the United States, and shall be convicted of having deserted the same, shall suffer death, or such other punishment as, by sentence of a court-martial, shall be inflicted.
"No officer or soldier in the army of the United States shall be subject to the punishment of death, for desertion in time of peace."
the conclusion of this article, "The Sentence Carried Out" will appear in the next issue of this News Magazine References: Library Of Congress The Cry Is War by Taylor War Letters by Andrew Carroll U.S. Army Military History Institute Southern Invincibility by Wiley Sword Hard Tack And Coffee by John D. Billings A Brotherhood Of Valor by Jeffry D. Wert Soldiers Blue and Gray by James Robertson Customs Of Service For Officers Of The Army Fighting Men Of The Civil War by William C. Davis Regulations for the Army of the United States Revised 1861 Customs Of Service For Non-Commissioned Officers And Soldiers February 13, 14, 15, 2004. The 26th annual and 140th anniversary Battle of Olustee (in north Florida) Olustee Battlefield Park. This event is a Hardy's Brigade 2nd Battalion maximum effort event. The reenactment takes place on the actual site where the Battle of Olustee (Ocean Pond) was fought. Visit with thousands of Civil War reenactors, tour the camps see demonstrations of all types. Best gathering of Civil War sutlers at any Civil War event with 80+ sutlers in attendance. Friday is School Day. Battles Saturday and Sunday. Reenactors should visit the Web site at http://extlab7.entnem.ufl.edu/olustee/ for applications, regulations and schedule. First time visitors to the event should read The Authentic Spectator at http://extlab7.entnem.ufl.edu/olustee/advice.htm No reenactor registration fee. Full scale artillery only. NO PETS. Due to concerns for public safety, no fur bearing animals such as cats and dogs will be allowed during the reenactment activities. This does not apply to horses. Get here early. The crowds gets big fast and sign-in and parking can be a hassle. The battlefield is located just fifteen miles east of Lake City on Hwy. 90 from I-75 and 50 miles west of Jacksonville. Take I-75 to Hwy. 90 exit. Go east on Hwy. 90. Drive slow, the signs at the entrance for reenactors have been small and hard to see in the past. There is an outstanding web site for this event at http://extlab7.entnem.ufl.edu/Olustee/ The Olustee event is worth the drive. Contact, Olustee Battlefield State Historic Site (386) 758-0400 or (386) 397-4461 Email olusteecso@yahoo.com February 20, 21, 22, 2004. The Battle of Ballast Point. Fort DeSoto Park, Pinellas County, Florida. The 97th Pennsylvania Volunteer Infantry Re-enactment Regiment, in cooperation with the Friends of Fort DeSoto, Inc., will host an American Civil War Weekend Encampment and Historical Battle Re-enactment at the Fort DeSoto Park located in Tierra Verde on the Southern-most tip of Pinellas County, Florida. The Civil War era camps will be open FREE to the public from 10:00 am until 5:00 pm. each day. Participants will be depicting both Union and Confederate infantry, artillery, cavalry (limited), and civilian impressions. On Friday, February 20, 2004, the camps will be open for tours by elementary school children from surrounding cities and counties. On Saturday and Sunday, camps will be open to the public with ongoing events all day, climaxing with an historical battle re-enactment each afternoon at 1:00 pm. Other Civil War activities will include period sutlers and vendors, a mock military trial and execution, artillery demonstrations, infantry drills, ladies afternoon tea, drum and fife music performances and civil war medical demonstrations. A limited number of modern camping spaces will be available on a first contact, first served basis. Contact us for your reservation now because modern campers showing up on the day of the event without a reservation will not be allowed to camp. The 97th PA will provide firewood, hay, and ice. A powder ration will be given for the first two Union and first two Confederate Artillery Pieces reserved. The host encourages reenactors to Arrive on Friday, February 20, 2004 to participate in their school day program for school children in Pinellas County. The host asks participating units and artillery to let them know in advance if they are coming to the event. For more information, contact David Glenn at email: coa_97thpa@hotmail.com or write to: 97th Pennsylvania Vol. Inf., Fort DeSoto Committee, 14172 Sharon Drive, Largo, Florida, 33774. Check the park's website at: http://www.pinellascounty.org/park/05_Ft_DeSoto.htm February 20, 21, 22, 2004. NEW EVENT. The Southeast Spring Drum & Fife Muster. Fort DeSoto Park, Pinellas County, Florida. The 97th Pennsylvania Volunteer Infantry Re-enactment Regiment, in conjunction with the American Civil War Weekend Encampment and Historical Battle Re-enactment at the Fort DeSoto Park located in Tierra Verde on the Southern-most tip of Pinellas County, Florida. They will be hosting a Regional Drum & Fife Muster event. All Civil War Musicians (Union, Confederate, and period Civilian) are invited and encouraged to attend. Participants will get to play, demonstrate, and share their music with other Civil War musicians from around the region. There will be informal sessions as well as formal, marching opportunities. A limited number of modern camping spaces will be available on a first contact, first served basis. Contact them for your reservation now because modern campers showing up on the day of the event without a reservation will not be allowed to camp. The 97th PA will provide firewood, hay, and ice. The host encourages re-enactors to arrive on Friday, February the 20th to participate in the school day program for school children in Pinellas County. They would like to ask participating musicians to reserve their spot for this event. For more information, contact David Glenn at (727) 595-5395, email: coa_97thpa@hotmail.com or write to: 97th Pennsylvania Vol. Inf., Fort DeSoto Committee, 14172 Sharon Drive, Largo, Florida, 33774. Check the park's website at: http://www.pinellascounty.org/park/05_Ft_DeSoto.htm February 20, 21, 22, 2004. Battle of Aiken in South Carolina. I have had a lot of good comments from reenactors who have attended this event. For all the information, driving directions, pre-registration and contact people go to their website at http://www.battleofaiken.org February 26, 2004. Thursday. The Greater Orlando Civil War Roundtable meets every 4th Thursday at 730pm. The meetings are held at the Marks Street Senior Center at 99 E. Marks St. between Orange Ave. and Magnolia St. in downtown Orlando. This months topic is "Conspiracy Theories Surrounding The Assassination Of President Abraham Lincoln" and will be presented by Joe Mee. For information contact Ruth Ann Wood at cwldy@mybluelight.com February 28, 2004.
Wetlands
Park Festival. Near Ft. Christmas Park in Christmas Fl. (east
side
of Orlando). Living history and possible recruiting
opportunity.
The host of this event is looking for a variety of historical
reenactors
and living historians to come to the Orlando Wetlands Park
Festival.
Their goal is to help educate the public and the kids who show up at
this
event about Florida, its environment and its history. Aprox.
1,500
spectators are expected to attend between 9am and 3pm Saturday.
For
more information, contact Mark Sees at mark.sees@cityoforlando.net
Your Obedient Servant,
This News Magazine, its articles, photos and all the
Home / Back Issue Contents / Contact the Editor Designed by Dixie Myst Designs copyright ©2004 |